I’m more interested in the questions an SEO provider asks than the rankings they promise. Before someone talks about keywords, I want to know whether they understand what the business sells, who it needs to reach, and what makes an inquiry worth answering.
That tells me more than a proposal full of technical language.
After more than 20 years in marketing, I don’t look at SEO as a separate job that happens somewhere behind the website. It affects website decisions, content, reputation, and lead generation. Hiring someone who understands only the search part can leave a business with better visibility and the same sales problem.
Here’s what I’d want a business owner to understand before signing an agreement.
Know What You Actually Need SEO to Accomplish
“I want to rank higher” is a starting point. It isn’t enough direction to build a plan around.
Rank higher for what? In which market? For which service? And what should happen after someone finds you?
I usually start with the business priorities. A company might need more repair calls but have all the installation work it can handle. A professional services firm might need fewer inquiries from people who aren’t a fit and more from decision-makers with a specific problem.
Those differences should change the work.
Before you interview anyone, write down the services you want to grow, the places you can realistically serve, and what a qualified lead looks like. Include any capacity limits. There’s little value in attracting work your team can’t take on.
A good provider should help sharpen those answers. If the conversation jumps straight to search volume without discussing business value, I’d slow it down.
A Local SEO Strategy Should Reflect How Your Business Operates
Working with businesses across Alabama, Mississippi, and Tennessee has reinforced something simple: a market on a map isn’t necessarily the market a business can serve profitably.
An HVAC business in the Shoals might serve customers across several nearby communities. A healthcare office generally needs patients willing to travel to a physical location. A manufacturer in North Alabama may need buyers several states away.
Those businesses shouldn’t receive the same local SEO strategy just because they’re based in Alabama.
Ask a prospective provider to explain the role of Google Maps results, regular website results, and your Google Business Profile. Which matters most for your customers? What can reasonably improve, and what limitations exist?
Distance affects local results. Someone searching near your location may see something different from a person searching across the county. That’s one reason a single ranking screenshot doesn’t tell the whole story.
I’d also be cautious about proposals built around dozens of nearly identical city pages. A location page should help a customer understand something useful about your service in that area. Changing the city name in otherwise identical copy isn’t much of a plan.
The Website May Need Work Before More Traffic Helps
After launching more than 100 websites, I’ve learned to question the assumption that a traffic problem is only a traffic problem.
A website can attract the right person and still lose the opportunity. Maybe the service description is vague. Maybe the phone number is hard to find on a mobile screen. Maybe the contact form asks for too much information before the visitor has any reason to trust the business.
My career started in graphic design and art direction, so I care about how a website looks. But good-looking pages don’t excuse a confusing path to becoming a customer.
Before hiring someone, open your website on your phone. Pick a service a customer might need. Can you quickly understand what’s offered, where it’s available, and how to take the next step?
Then ask the provider what they would change.
They don’t need to give you a complete unpaid audit. But they should be able to explain whether the site has technical barriers, weak service pages, or usability problems that could limit the value of SEO.
Also ask who will make those changes. Recommendations sitting in a document won’t fix the website.
Ask for Priorities, Not Just a List of Tasks
SEO proposals can make activity look like progress. Monthly articles, directory submissions, technical checks, and reports may all have a place. The question is why those tasks deserve attention now.
I’d rather see a short, well-explained set of priorities than a long checklist with no connection to the business.
Ask: “Based on what you know so far, what would you address first, and why?”
A thoughtful answer will acknowledge what still needs investigation. It might begin with checking whether important pages can appear in search, correcting business information, or improving thin service descriptions. Not every business needs more blog posts right away.
Have the provider separate initial cleanup from ongoing work. Ask what the monthly fee includes, what costs extra, and what requires your team’s involvement.
Someone will probably need to confirm service details, review content, provide photos, or explain the questions customers ask. If you’re too busy to handle that, assign a person internally before the work starts.
Clear responsibilities matter as much as a good plan.
Be Careful With Guarantees and Work You Can’t Inspect
No provider controls Google’s results. A promise to put you first for every important search is a reason to ask harder questions, not a reason to sign faster.
I’m equally cautious about anyone who won’t explain their methods in plain language. You don’t need to learn every technical detail. You do need to understand what someone is doing under your business’s name.
Ask how they approach links, content, and reviews. Paying for links intended to manipulate rankings can create problems. So can fabricated reviews, fake business locations, or large amounts of inaccurate content published without review.
Confidential processes aren’t an excuse for secrecy about work that could affect your reputation.
Ownership belongs in this conversation too. Your business should retain control of its domain, website, Google Business Profile, analytics, and Search Console accounts. A provider can receive the access needed to work without becoming the only person who holds the keys.
Before signing, ask what happens if you leave. Know what you keep, what gets transferred, and whether any part of the website depends on a subscription you’ll lose.
Agree on How Progress Will Be Judged
I’ve worked across website strategy, SEO, Google Ads, and analytics. That combination makes me skeptical of reports that celebrate clicks without explaining what happened next.
More traffic can be useful. It can also come from people researching jobs, looking for instructions, or seeking something you don’t sell.
A useful report connects search visibility to relevant visits and meaningful actions. That might include calls, appointment requests, quote forms, or inquiries about particular services. It should also explain the work completed and what the provider recommends next.
Ask how those actions will be measured before work begins. Form submissions aren’t automatically qualified leads, and a clicked phone number doesn’t prove a conversation happened. Your team’s feedback about inquiry quality helps fill those gaps.
Timing needs the same honesty. Technical fixes may be completed quickly, but meaningful search improvements often take months. Competition, website history, and the amount of work required all affect that timeline.
I wouldn’t accept an exact deadline for a ranking. I would expect milestones for work the provider controls, regular reviews, and a willingness to change direction if the evidence calls for it.
Patience is reasonable. Paying indefinitely without a clear explanation of progress isn’t.
Bottom Line
I’d hire the person who can explain the problem, defend the priorities, and connect the work to the business—not the person promising the most keywords on page one.
You don’t need to become an SEO specialist to make a sound decision. Know which customers you want, keep control of your accounts, and ask how the work will produce better opportunities. The right provider should make those conversations clearer, not harder.
Brian "JR" Williamson
Founder & Marketing Director
20+ Years in Marketing Strategy • SEO • Websites • Brand & Digital Growth
Florence / The Shoals, Alabama
Jackson, Tennessee